Thursday, September 24, 2015

4 Different Generations, 4 Different Way to Communicate

How to improve the communication between very different groups of people

In order to effectively communicate between the different generations, it is important to understand their differences and their unique approach to life. It begins with values that are important to each generation. For example, while the Baby Boomers put a lot of emphasis on work, the Generation X’s would rather find a good work/life balance.

There is an article from Colorado State University that addresses each of the four recent generations:

Traditionalists

Traditionalists values are influenced by the experiences of their parents whose values go back to the 1800s. This generation experienced the Great Depression and World War II both of which shape how they view the world.
Traditionalists Value
  • Privacy: Traditionalists are the private, silent generation. Don't expect members of this generation to share their inner thoughts.
  • Hard Work: They believe in paying their dues and become irritated when they perceive others are wasting their time. Members of this generation often feel that their career identifies who they are.
  • Trust: A traditionalist's word is his/her bond.
  • Formality: Whether written or in oral communication a formal communication style is preferred. This generation values formal dress and organizational structures.
  • Authority and institutional leadership: Traditionalists have a great deal of respect for authority.
  • Social Order: Other generations may view this desire for social order and placement as bias, prejudice or even racism or sexism.
  • Things: This group loves their stuff and they won't get rid of it. Some may call them pack rats but others would argue that they remember the depression days and going with out. You never know when you might need it.

Supportive Behaviors and Tips For Communicating with Traditionalists
  • By nature Traditionalists are private, the "silent generation". Don't expect members of this generation to share their thoughts immediately.
  • For the Traditionalist an educator's word is his/her bond, so it's important to focus on words rather than body language or inferences.
  • Face to face or written communication is preferred.
  • Don't waste their time, or let them feel as though their time is being wasted.

Baby Boomers
Morris Massey calls this group the Nuagers. This generation represents the children of our World War II veterans. They did not go through economically hard times as their parents did, they had the good life - the Traditionalists wanted them to have the best and as a result, the "Me" decade arrived.

Baby Boomers Value
  • Competition: Boomers value peer competition and can be see by others as being egocentric.
  • Change: Boomers thrive for possibilities and constant change.
  • Hard Work: Boomers started the "workaholic" trend. The difference between Traditionalists and Boomers is that Boomers value the hard work because they view it as necessary for moving to the next level of success while Traditionalists work hard because they feel that it is the right thing to do.
  • Success: This generation is committed to climbing the ladder of success.
  • Body Language: Boomers are the show me generation and body language is important.
  • Teamwork: This group embraces a team based approach to business-they are eager to get rid of the command and control style of their Traditionalist predecessors.
  • Anti Rules and Regulations: They don't appreciate rules for the sake of having rules and they will challenge the system.
  • Inclusion: This generation will accept people on an equal basis as long as they can perform to their standards.
  • Will Fight For A Cause: While they don't like problems, if you give them a cause they will fight for it.

Supportive Behaviors & Tips For Communicating With Baby Boomers
  • Boomers are the "show me" generation, so your body language is important when communicating.
  • Speak in an open, direct style but avoid controlling language.
  • Answer questions thoroughly and expect to be pressed for the details.
  • Present options to demonstrate flexibility in your thinking.

Generation Xers
Morris Massey refers to this group as the Syn-Tech generation. This generation is both economically conservative, remembering double-digit inflation and the stress that their parents faced during times of on and off unemployment. Unlike their predecessors, they will not rely on institutions for their long-term security.


Generation Xers Value
  • Entrepreneurial Spirit: Xers believe in investing in their own development rather than in their organization's. While others may see them as disloyal they are cautious about investing in relationships with employers because experience has shown that these relationships are not reliable. Cavalier as it may sound, one Xer told a Boomer that if you want loyalty get a dog.
  • Loyalty: To an Xer, this may mean two-weeks notice.
  • Independence and Creativity: Xers have clear goals and prefer managing their own time and solving their own problems rather than having them managed by a supervisor.
    Information: They value access to information and love plenty of it.
  • Feedback: This group needs continuous feedback and they use the feedback to adapt to new situations. This generation is flexible.
  • Quality of Worklife: This generation works hard but they would rather find quicker more efficient ways of working so that they have time for fun. While Boomers are working hard to move up the ladder, Xers are working hard so that they can have more time to balance work and life responsibilities.

Supportive Behaviors & Tips for Communicating With Generation X
  • Use email as a primary communication tool.
  • Talk in short sound bites to keep their attention.
  • Ask them for their feedback and provide them with regular feedback.
  • Share information with them on a regular basis and strive to keep them in the loop.
  • Use an informal communication style.

Generation Y (Also Called Nexters)
If you think that Generation Xers were challenging for Traditionalists and Boomers to teach, just wait until Generation Y arrives. Generation Y represents people who have grown up during the high tech revolution. They have never known a world without high speed video games, speed dial and ATMs. The secret to motivating this group is to provide systematic and frequent feedback - as it happens.


Generation Y Values
  • Positive Reinforcement: Members of this cyber generation value positive reinforcement at accelerated rates compared to older generations.
  • Autonomy: This group wants more input into how they are learning and the independence to do it.
  • Positive Attitudes: This group grew up during tranquil times and as a result have a very optimistic outlook on life in general.
  • Diversity: This group grew up with more diversity than their predecessors and if not exposed to it in their community then they were introduced diverse people and cultures through the media.
  • Money: This group is used to making and spending money.
  • Technology: Technology is valued and is used as a tool for multi-tasking.

Supportive Behaviors & Tips for Communicating With Generation Y
  • Use action words and challenge them at every opportunity.
  • They will resent it if you talk down to them.
  • They prefer email communication.
  • Seek their feedback constantly and provide them with regular feedback.
  • Use humor and create a fun learning environment. Don't take yourself too seriously.
  • Encourage them to take risks and break the rules so that they can explore new ways of learning.

Managing the Generational Mix
How do we keep a generationally diverse group of learners motivated in today's environment? The first step to making the generational diversity work is to understand what motivates members of different generations and to institute teaching techniques that are flexible enough to meet their needs. In today's complex mix of generations, Traditionalists are found with Boomers and Boomers with Generation Xers. Trends toward later retirements mean that traditionalists are still happy working and learning and Generation Xers are quickly moving into positions of power and influence where they are supervising and educating members of older generations.

For information on topics relating to HR, HIPAA, OSHA, and Medicare, please email support@hcsiinc.com or visit our web site at http://www.hcsiinc.com

Wednesday, September 23, 2015

Hire the Right Employee

Hiring the right employee for the right position will save your practice both time and money.

Judy has just given you her two weeks’ notice. Her position is a critical part of your practice. You spend time advertising the job opening. You spend more time interviewing many “awesome” candidates. An offer for the position is extended and accepted. You take a deep sigh of relief that all is well. However, about 90 days into the new person’s employment things are not going well and they are not going to work out. Make that 60 days . . . nope, 30 days . . . you knew it within the first week. It’s time to cut ties are start over. More time and money spent on the hiring process.

Due to the high turnover rate in the medical field, it is especially important to have an effective hiring system in place. When you hire the right employee, it reflects well for both the person who made the hiring decision and the practice. If a person is hired due to a poor hiring decision, it opens up the possibility of lawsuits, negative culture change, lower morale among other employee, and a decrees in performance. Hiring the right employee for the right position is one of the most important decisions your practice will ever make.

Step #1: Define the Job

Know the exact job duties a new employee would perform and the knowledge, skills, and abilities (KSA) required for the position and then assess whether hiring a new employee is the best option. Many organizations make the mistake of hiring a new employee as soon as they perceive that there is a need. It is very important for the employer to know exactly what job duties a new employee would perform and to assess whether hiring a new employee is the best option. If you do decide to hire a new employee, then you will need to write a job posting. Be sure to write the job posting based on the KSA’s a person will need in order to be successful at the open position.

Step #2: Develop an Applicant Pool

Create a pool of applicants from which you will pick your new employee. This pool can be generated using a variety of sources including, but not limited to current employees, referrals, colleges/universities, employment agencies, internet job sites, job fairs, and radio.

Step #3: Applicant Selection Process

Use a uniform process to evaluate and rate each candidate and select the one best suited for the open position. This process should include, interviews, applicant rating (on KSA’a and culture fit), pre-employment tests, and notification of unqualified candidates.

Step #4: Final Selection Process

Before a hiring decision is made, all interested parties should have the opportunity to interview each final candidate. This final interview is important as it generates buy-in from the decision makers within the practice. Each final candidate should be ranked by every person who interviews them. Once the interview are complete, have a meeting between all of the individuals who interviewed the candidate to get their feedback and rankings. After all of the information has been gathered and assessed, it is time to make the hiring decision. Before making an offer to the selected candidate, it is important that you conduct a background check on the selected candidate. Once the background check has been done and you are satisfied with the results, an offer should be extended to the selected candidate. Be sure the job offer is officially accepted, before notifying the other candidates who were not selected. Once the job offer is accepted, you can begin the new-hire process.

Hiring the right employee will save your practice time, money, strengthen your organizational culture, limit your liability, keep your other employees happy, and make your practice more productive.

For any questions on this or other HR, HIPAA, OSHA, or Medicare related products, please email us at support@hcsiinc.com or visit our web site at http://www.hcsiinc.com.

Tuesday, September 22, 2015

Proper PHI Disposal

Dispose of PHI properly and help eliminate this area of potential liability



When PHI and ePHI is no longer needed by your office or you have maintained your archived records for the specified period of time, it is vital that these documents and electronic document be disposed of properly. By disposing of these documents and electronic documents properly, you are greatly lessening your chance of this critical area of compliance being a liability for your organization or practice.

In general, examples of proper disposal methods may include, but are not limited to:
• For PHI in paper records, shredding, burning, pulping, or pulverizing the records so that PHI is rendered essentially unreadable, indecipherable, and otherwise cannot be reconstructed.
• Maintaining labeled prescription bottles and other PHI in opaque bags in a secure area and using a disposal vendor as a business associate to pick up and shred or otherwise destroy the PHI.
• For PHI on electronic media, clearing (using software or hardware products to overwrite media with non-sensitive data), purging (degaussing or exposing the media to a strong magnetic field in order to disrupt the recorded magnetic domains), or destroying the media (disintegration, pulverization, melting, incinerating, or shredding).

In addition to the properly disposing of PHI and ePHI, it is important to remember that you must also properly dispose of all PHI that has been accessed by any electronic device. If the device is no longer going to be used, it is very difficult to properly dispose of the ePHI files on these devices, so HIPAA suggest the entire device is destroyed.

Properly disposing of all PHI and ePHI is improve greatly reduce the risk of a health information breach, thus improving your chances of avoiding a violation fine.

For more information on protecting your office with this issue and other HIPAA, HR, OSHA, and Medicare topics, please visit our web site: http://www.hcsiinc.com or email support at support@hcsiinc.com.

Source: http://bit.ly/1MGGOlm

Monday, September 21, 2015

Improve the Smell, Increase the Production

How Foul Odor Affects the Workplace


We have all been in “that” situation. You have in the past or are currently working with somebody who’s smell makes your eyes water. All could think about is getting away from that person and giving your nose a break. It was time for lunch and you thought you had a little break from the stink, but it was not the case. The smelly person asked you to go to lunch with her. You press forward with your day . . . and the smell.


Offensive odors in the workplace are an issue that need to be taken seriously. Any type of foul odor could be a distraction for the other employees and will lead to a decrease in productivity. In addition to the decrease in productivity, some odors could be a health concern for employees with asthma or other health challenges.

Offending odors include, but are not limited to:
  • Poor personal hygiene habits (body odor or bad breath)
  • Excessive perfume or cologne
  • Tobacco smoke
  • Flatulence

It is important to have a detailed odor policy in your workplace. This type of policy will help eliminate the majority of possible odor offenses. If a situation does arise, you will have this established policy to support you when handling the offense. Here are some tips in dealing with such a situation:

·         Start with a soft approach to set the employee at ease, but don't beat around the bush.
·         Tell the employee directly what the problem is as you perceive it and remind them about the policy in your workplace.
·         Whenever possible, attach the feedback to a business issue, such as the impact on the team.
·         Advise that the behavior is not just affecting the business and the employee's co-workers, but may affect the employee's career.
·         Be sensitive to the fact that different cultures have different norms and standards for appearance, bathing, and dress and differences in cooking and eating traditions, too.

These type of situation are often uncomfortable for you and the offending employee, but these situations must be dealt with quickly and in a professional manner. Ensure that any incoming employees are aware of your odor policy. If you do not have an odor policy in place, put one together and make it official.

Offensive odor in the workplace is a serious issue that will impact your employee’s productivity, health, and the culture of your workplace as well.

For any assistance in this or other matters relating to HR, HIPAA, OSHA, or Medicare please contact us at support@hcsiinc.com or view our web site at http://www.hcsiinc.com


Tuesday, September 15, 2015

Avoid Legal Trouble By Documenting Your I9's Correctly

Maintaining I-9s: Top Ten Do’s and Don’ts

Don’t get sloppy with your I-9 employment eligibility verification forms.
This year, the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) will initiate a great deal of
paperwork audits looking at I-9s. USCIS also increasingly brings cases against employers under the criminal code, rather than civil penalties. It made more than 900 criminal arrests last year, up from 72 arrests five years ago.

Penalties: Poor documentation can cost you $1000 per worker, and knowingly hiring an illegal immigrant can result in a $10,000-per-worker fine.

To sidestep potential legal trouble and discrimination complaints, follow these ten I-9 do’s and don’ts:
1. Do require all new hires to complete and sign Section 1 on their first day of work.
2. Don’t ask an applicant to complete an I-9 prior to making a job offer. Unhired applicants
can use I-9 information to allege that you discriminated against them.
3. Do review employee documents to make sure they’re on the new version of the I-9’s list of
acceptable documents and that they appear genuine. (See the new I-9 on our web site at
www.hcsiinc.com on the “Updates/News” link.)
4. Don’t ask new hires for any particular documents or for more documents than the I-9
requires. The employee chooses the documents, not you.
5. Do establish a consistent procedure for completing I-9s, and educate your hiring managers on the procedure.
6. Don’t consider the expiration date of I-9 documentation when making hiring or firing
decisions.
7. Do make and retain copies of all I-9 documents provided. (Only a few states make this
mandatory, but it’s a good idea.)
8. Don’t forget to keep a tickler file to follow up on expiring documents that limit the
employee’s authorization to work. You don’t have to re-verify identity documents, such as a
driver’s license.
9. Do keep I-9s and copies of documents for three years after the employee’s hire date or one
year after his or her termination, whichever comes first.
10. Don’t put the I-9 in an employee’s personnel file. To protect against discrimination claims,
keep it and supporting documentation in a separate file. 

HIPAA Violations and Social Networking

Social Networking Is Putting Your Practice at Risk

Many healthcare organizations are using social networks (Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, etc.) as a means of connected with their client base, or as a means of advertising their services. Whether your practice is using these social networks or not, you
can reasonably assume that your employees are using these sites to expand their own personal social network. This can present a huge problem! 

Employees who frequently use these sites as a way of sharing the events of their personal lives are very likely to discuss work on-line as well. Social network sites create a huge risk for HIPAA violations, and also for employee relation problems.

HIPAA violations occurring on these popular social media sites demand employers establish guidelines for social network use. Because healthcare workers normally access them on personal time away from work, employers should discuss the importance of these guidelines.

Employers should generally prohibit employees from including any information about patients on their social network pages, even if patients have given them permission to do so. It is also recommended that you prohibit your employees from linking to a patient’s social network page. We encourage you to prohibit your employees from accessing these social networking pages while at work using your office computer.

Individuals are free to disclose any information they choose on their social network pages, including their own personal PHI. However, you should be sensitive about your employees linking to these pages at work because of the appearance of impropriety and the distinct possibility of a HIPAA violation. Employers cannot control their employee’s lives and social media activity, EXCEPT as it relates to work.

Monday, September 14, 2015

Poor Management Cost Your Business Money

9 Signs of Poor Managers in Your Healthcare Office


When employees are dissatisfied at work, one of their most common complaints is about poor management. Dissatisfaction at work causes an increase in turnover and that costs your business money! For employers interested in improving employee morale and workplace culture, the idea of “poor management” is too general. What causes the perception of poor management? What exactly are the most common complaints about poor or ineffective managers?

The Harvard Business Review actually did a survey on this topic, and it created a list of the most common complaints about ineffective managers. The Harvard study labeled these items as “The Communication Issues That Prevent Effective Leadership,” and it’s easy to see why: these items clearly would hinder a good working environment.
Here’s what the study found, ranked by frequency:

1.      Not recognizing employee achievements
2.      Not giving clear directions
3.      Not having time to meet with employees
4.      Refusing to talk to subordinates
5.      Taking credit for others’ ideas
6.      Not offering constructive criticism
7.      Not knowing employees’ names
8.      Refusing to talk to people on the phone/in person
9.      Not asking about employees’ lives outside work

Some of them may be surprising to many of us, such as not knowing employees’ names. Such things seem like they would fall under basic courtesy—and when basic courtesy and good management are lacking, employee morale can easily be lacking as well.
In order to help prevent your business from wasting money, it is important to have effective leadership. By having effective leadership, you will notice an increase in employee satisfaction, and thus a decrease in turnover. Having a decrease in turnover alone will lead to you saving your business money!

(BLR website)

Wednesday, September 9, 2015

Double Gloving Can Protect You

Benefits of Double Gloving
                                                           
Healthcare providers observed blood on their hands after surgery more frequently when they wore a single pair of gloves than when they wore two pairs of gloves and generally had a favorable opinion on double gloving, according to a recent study.
                                                           
The study, appearing in a recent article of the AORN (Association of periOperative Registered Nurses) Journal, examines the effect of double gloving with inner indicator gloves on the durability of inner gloves and the detection of glove tears or perforations during surgery.
                                                           
“Double gloving by itself may protect the wearer’s skin from needle sticks because breaches are more likely to occur to the outer gloves than the inner gloves,” according to the study’s authors, Denise Korniewicz, PhD, RN, FAAN, and Maher El-Masri, PhD, RN.
                                                           
The study also found that healthcare providers who wore dark-colored gloves under light-colored gloves changed them during surgery with significantly more frequency than those who wore two pairs of the same color. 

Tuesday, September 8, 2015

Is This a Breach?

Potential HIPAA PHI Breach

Q: We found medical records about one of our patients in our parking lot. Is this a breach? What should we do?

A: With all the focus on keeping electronic records secure, a lot of paper records still exist. In this instance, the patient or his or her legal representative may have dropped the paperwork by accident. Or, more ominously, a staff member could have dropped them.

You should certainly do whatever you can to investigate how the records got to the parking lot and look into who might have seen them. When you have completed your investigation, you will be able to determine whether the incident is likely to cause harm to the patient. If you conclude that no harm was done, you do not have to report the incident to the patient or to HHS. That said, it is always wise to be as transparent as possible, and this would include notifying the patient.


In addition, it would be appropriate to remind your staff members that they should not take PHI out of the building. If you determine that someone removed the information for a legitimate purpose, you may want to purchase lockable bags for those who must transport PHI.

Friday, September 4, 2015

OSHA Needle-stick Injury Checklist

Needle-stick Injury Checklist

The following is a checklist for you to follow in the event of a needle-stick:
● Immediately wash the exposed area with soap and water.
● Notify your OSHA Compliance Officer.
● Notify doctor “of record” for the patient.
● If the source is known to be HIV positive, OR is at high risk, THIS IS AN EMERGENCY! (In this situation, the employee SHOULD have been double gloved!).
● Offer Chemoprophylaxis (PEP) within 1-2 hours.
● Obtain consent from “source“ to draw blood.
● Source Patient: Draw a “STAT” HIV screen, HBsAg, HbsAb, and Hep C Ab.
● The “STAT” HIV screen needs an EDTA (purple) tube, the rest require serum. One purple top and one 6-8 cc serum tube is needed.
● If the source is NOT infected with a bloodborne pathogen, no further baseline testing is required on the employee.
● Perform Anti-HCV and ALT testing in 4-6 months.
● A previously vaccinated known responder to HBV requires no further testing.
● Perform HIV-antibody testing at 6 weeks, 3 months, and 6 months post-exposure.
● Complete Sharps Injury Log.
● Lastly, complete your Post-Exposure Checklist.

Thursday, September 3, 2015

14 Questions for RAC Self-Audits

RAC Self-Auditing

Here are 14 simple questions that will give you peace of mind regarding your RAC self-audits.

Randomly select 10 Medicare patient records then apply these simple questions to each record: 
  1. Are the services and supplies proper and needed for diagnosis and treatment of the diagnosis?
  2. Do any charges appear to be “unbundled”?
  3. Does the procedure code correctly describe the service provided?
  4. Are the HCPCS and/or CPT codes updated and correct?
  5. Are the E and M codes used appropriate and does the documentation support their use?
  6. Are the modifiers used properly?
  7. Were the correct and updated ICD-9 or ICD-10 CM codes linked to the diagnoses and procedure code(s)?
  8. Is the place of service appropriate?
  9. Are there duplicate services rendered on the same date?
  10. Does the documentation support the services billed?
  11. Is the medical record clearly written, accurate and complete?
  12. Is there any evidence of “intentional deception”?
  13. Did the billing provider actually render the service?
  14. Were all billed services actually rendered?

Wednesday, September 2, 2015

Employee Classification

Classifying Your Employees

Federal and State laws generally do not define the terms of full-time, part-time or temporary employees.  This leaves the employer with the flexibility to categorize their employees. Most often, these classifications are based on the number of hours worked and the duties performed.  Typically the classification determines eligibility for benefits.

Basis for Classification

Employees usually fall into three major categories:

·         Full-time
·         Part-time
·         Temporary

You may want to use the eligibility requirements under your insurance benefit plans (many health care plans exclude part-time employees who work less than a specific number of hours per week)

However, the definition chosen will not affect the employee’s eligibility for legally mandated benefits, such as worker’ compensation, unemployment compensation, unpaid family and medical leave and military leave.

Also note that the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) further classifies employees as eligible or ineligible for overtime pay and refers to them as being either exempt or non-exempt from the Act’s provisions.

Full-time Employees

A full-time employee is generally defined as one who works a normal workweek for an indefinite period of time.  Since the FSLA sets 40 hours as the maximum number of hours worked before employers must pay overtime to non-exempt employees, you may use that number as their normal work week.  (You can also use 37 ½ hours or even 35 hours, depending on business hours and meal schedules.) Full-time employment could also be defined according to part-time employment hours.  For example, if part-time employment is defined as 30 hours a week, then someone who works more than 30 hours per week could be classified as full-time.

Part-time Employees

Part-time employees work fewer hours than the normal full-time schedule, but are employed on an ongoing basis and typically receive some benefits.  Part-time employment may mean irregular hours or workdays.  A common definition or part-time employment is an employee who works less than 30 hours per week.

Employers may choose to provide their part-time employees with a pro-rata share of benefits such as sick leave, vacation and other paid absences based on the number of hours worked.

Temporary Employees

Temporary employees may work full or part-time hours.  What makes the employee status “temporary” is that the worker is hired for a particular project or for a finite period of time.  Because of the short-term nature of employment, temporary employees generally do not receive any benefits other than those required by law.

Some practices use temporary workers as a way to screen potential full-time candidates.  Because some temporary employees may have an increased expectation of advancing to regular employment and eligibility for benefits, employers should make it clear that temporary workers are being hired for a limited period of time and are not eligible for benefits.

Employers should explain the temporary nature of the job in a letter or other written document stating an approximate limit for the period that a worker is expected to be employed and give the option for the employer to extend as needed.


In addition, employers should monitor the status of temporary employees so that if a limited duration of their employees change, the employee can be reclassified and correctly offered benefits they may entitled to.  Failure to do so may conclude with a misunderstanding and potential legal claims.

Tuesday, September 1, 2015

HIPAA Privacy and Security Walk-Through Infographic


OSHA Introduces Early Resolution Whistle Blower Program

An Early Resolution Program for Whistle-Blower Claims
In an attempt to save money and time, the federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) has introduced an early resolution program for whistle-blowers and employers to settle disputes without investigations and litigation. State OSHA plans are strongly encouraged to also adopt the process.
The early resolution process offers whistle-blower parties the opportunity to negotiate a settlement with the assistance of a neutral, confidential OSHA representative with subject matter expertise in whistle-blower investigations, the agency said. It’s an expansion of a pilot program that’s been in place in selected OSHA regions since late 2012.
OSHA enforces the whistle-blower provisions of 22 statutes protecting employees who report violations of various securities laws; trucking, airline, nuclear power, pipeline, environmental, rail, maritime, health care, workplace safety and health regulations; and consumer product safety laws.
“The number of retaliation claims filed under the various statutes has risen steadily each year and the cost of investigating them has placed a tremendous strain on OSHA’s fiscal and physical resources,” said Valerie Butera, a labor and employment attorney. OSHA accepted 3,060 new whistle-blower cases in fiscal year 2014.
The pilot of the early resolution process proved to be a very effective and viable alternative to the investigative process, and an invaluable asset to OSHA’s whistle-blower protection programs, the agency said. “The process demonstrated that adding staff dedicated to the coordination and facilitation of settlement negotiations provides valuable relief to OSHA’s whistle-blower investigative staff, and provides a highly desired service.”
Workers or employers from the targeted regions made 289 requests to attempt to reach a settlement using the early resolution process during 2013, the first fiscal year it was available, according to OSHA. Both parties agreed to attempt a settlement in 87 of those cases. In the end, 54 cases were settled.
The directive does not prohibit OSHA whistle-blower offices from offering complainants and respondents other alternative dispute-resolution processes, such as third-party mediation.
The process involved in the early resolution program is outlined below.
●        Upon receiving a timely complaint—within 30 days of the retaliatory act—OSHA will send opening letters to both the respondent and the complainant informing the parties about OSHA’s early resolution program and the option to use it.
●        If both parties agree to seek early resolution at any time after an investigation begins, the investigation will be suspended and the case handed over to the regional alternative dispute-resolution coordinator. The coordinator will work with the parties to explore whether there is common ground for settlement but will not judge the merits of the complaint.
●        OSHA can terminate the process if either party violates the ground rules for participation, including engaging in abusive behavior or failing to participate in good faith, or if the parties cannot come to an agreement within a reasonable amount of time. “Parties must come to the process fully prepared to discuss resolution of the whistle-blower complaint and have full authority to settle the dispute,” Butera said.
●        Either party can also end the process, as participation is voluntary.
●        If the parties agree upon a framework for settlement, the coordinator may draft a proposed settlement agreement or the parties may draft and submit an agreement for OSHA’s approval. After the agency approves and both parties sign the settlement agreement, OSHA will close its investigation. If a settlement is not reached, the investigation will resume.
Butera advised employers to consider these core concepts:
●        The early resolution process is confidential. The coordinator will not discuss the merits of the complaint or the content of the early resolution discussions with OSHA’s investigators, but “keep in mind, however, that the terms of an OSHA whistle-blower settlement agreement, whether agreed upon during the early resolution process or by other means, will be disclosed to OSHA and may be made public by OSHA in response to a [Freedom of Information Act] request or otherwise,” Butera said.
●        Early resolution may significantly reduce the cost of responding to a whistle-blower complaint. “An investigation may disrupt your business, affecting productivity, and can lead to full-blown federal litigation,” Butera said. “It costs nothing to attempt to agree upon a resolution that satisfies the parties. OSHA even offers early resolution conferences by telephone in the event that travel to attempt early resolution would be too costly or create hardship for either party.”

(SHRM website)

Friday, August 28, 2015

Religious Discrimination Case Against UPS

New Ruling Shines Spotlight on Religious Discrimination

In July, the U.S. Equal Opportunity Commission sued the world’s largest package delivery service, United Parcel Services, claiming that UPS failed to hire, promote and accommodate Muslims, Rastafarians and Christians whose religions dictate grooming practices that UPS found objectionable. The lawsuit claims that UPS prohibits male employees who are supervisors or who have dealings with customers from wearing beards or growing their hair below collar length.

One example in the lawsuit is that of a Muslim applying for a driver’s helper position in New York who wears a beard as part of his religious beliefs. He was told to shave if he wanted the position and that “God would understand.” Another example in the lawsuit is that of a Rastafarian load supervisor in Fort Lauderdale who does not cut his hair as part of his religious beliefs and who was told “we don’t want any employees looking like women on management teams.”

The lawsuit against UPS comes on the heels of the U.S. Supreme Court ruling against retailer Abercrombie & Fitch on another religious discrimination claim. There, the company refused to hire a then 17-year-old woman in Oklahoma for a position at a store because she wore a “hijab,” or head scarf. The retailer claimed that the scarf, and all other head coverings, did not conform to the company’s dress code.

Both of these suits claim that the actions of the employers violated Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits employment discrimination based upon (among other things) religion. As the Supreme Court stated in its Abercrombie decision, “an employer may not make an applicant’s religious practice, confirmed or otherwise, a factor in employment decisions.”

Further, under Title VII, unless it would pose an undue hardship on the employer, an employer must make reasonable accommodations to its employees and cannot refuse to hire or promote an applicant/employee if the need for a religious accommodation is a motivating factor. “Undue hardship” on an employer is defined as an action that imposes “more than a minimal burden” on the business. Examples include causing a lack of necessary staffing, jeopardizing security, or costing the employer more than a minimal amount. What is considered “minimal” by an employer and the EEOC can vary significantly.

These cases make clear that religious discrimination is an area of strong interest (and enforcement attention) of the EEOC. It underscores the need for policies and practices that every employer should follow:

● Employers should ensure that managers know the EEOC guidelines, as well as the company’s policies, by providing periodic training to all managers. These trainings should especially cover policies relating to scheduling, dress codes and grooming standards – three of the most common areas of company policies that can run afoul of certain religious practices.

● There should be strict guidance provided to hiring managers prohibiting any jokes or sarcasm directed at any religious belief. These statements, even if made in a non-serious fashion, have no place in the workplace and often form objective proof of and the basis for claims.

● Hiring managers should be aware that an applicant is not required to make a specific request for a religious accommodation, nor may an employer make an adverse hiring, promotion or termination decision based upon “actual knowledge, suspicion or merely a hunch” that an applicant will request an accommodation.

● Policies should require that all managers inform their HR department if an existing or prospective employee requests an accommodation or if they believe such a request will be made.

● Hiring managers should not ask employees or applicants directly if they are groomed or wearing attire for religious reasons. This type of inquiry can lead to a discussion that may trigger a later religious discrimination claim.

● Employers should carefully consider all options available to them before denying an accommodation request, especially on the basis of undue hardship to the company.

Religious discrimination cases, even those resolved prior to any formal lawsuit, are costly and distracting for a business. Implementing an HR training program that reaches all levels of an organization is a wise investment in preventing discrimination of all types in the workplace.

(EBN website)